A troubling report: School bus safety a top priority
by The Anniston Star Editorial Board
Nov 23, 2009 | 839 views | 4 4 comments | 8 8 recommendations | email to a friend | print
Families of the four Lee High School students who died in the 2006 school bus crash in Huntsville expected revelations in last week's National Transportation Safety Board report. They didn't get them.

Instead, those families and state education officials heard much of what already was known: The crash probably occurred when a car driven by another Lee student collided with the bus while traveling on Interstate 565. No hidden cause was uncovered. The basic facts of the tragedy remain the same.

But don't believe the NTSB report was a wasted effort.

If anything, the government investigation proved that oversight of school bus operations must be stringent and airtight. Nothing else is acceptable. Any lapse in supervision of those who drive school buses, manage bus plans or coordinate bus repairs is a danger to the safety — and the lives — of children.

In its report, the NTSB said the bus' driver, Anthony Scott, was not wearing his seat belt. The crash ejected Scott from the bus — meaning no one was at the controls to attempt to stop the bus after it impacted a retaining wall on the interstate.

The NTSB report also said Scott had used marijuana within a week of the accident, but that he wasn't impaired by the illegal drug on the day of the crash.

No criminal charges were filed against Scott. Given the report's findings, that seems the appropriate decision. Positively, the crash has already led to several changes in national regulations for lap-and-shoulder belts and higher seat backs for certain buses.

However, the report does underscore the need for school officials to assess all aspects of bus operations. Scott wasn't wearing his seat belt — which didn't cause the crash, but certainly played a factor in his inability to control the bus after it hit the wall.

Additionally, the report's inclusion of marijuana use was troubling. Scott may not have been under the influence on the day of the Huntsville crash, but it is not a comforting sign for parents when they hear that an Alabama school-bus driver was linked to illegal drug use.

The actions of one person do not tarnish the collective reputation of the state's school bus drivers. Their dedication to the safety of the children they transport should not be questioned.

But parts of the NTSB report on the Huntsville crash give us pause. Checking the state's school bus operations seems a wise choice. We can never be too careful in protecting children's safety.
comments (4)
« alvinhurst@bellsouth.net wrote on Monday, Nov 23 at 11:58 AM »
Davy, I think that is true and one factor. I learned to drive a two ton truck in the fields and drove on the road at age 6. That was common back then. The sheriff even stopped a friend of mine while driving at age 9. He told him he was doing a good job but he shouldn't be driving on the public highway and let him go. Kids were just more mature back then.

And yeah, we shot guns at a young age. Some even took them to school for hunting after school. No problems. Can you imagine that now?
« anonymous wrote on Monday, Nov 23 at 11:30 AM »
The coefficient changed
« alvinhurst@bellsouth.net wrote on Monday, Nov 23 at 10:44 AM »
And we don't need any wise cracks about the buses back then being pulled by mules.
« alvinhurst@bellsouth.net wrote on Monday, Nov 23 at 10:42 AM »
My comment is not related to this specific accident but maybe we should let students drive the buses. I know that sounds crazy and it probably is. But when I was in school most of the drivers were students, 16 and 17 year olds. And I do not recall one single accident at my school in 12 years. Now there is some statistical correlation for the people who like to throw out statistical correlations and deem it cause and effect.

So what has changed. What is causing these accidents?