Oxford taxpayers paid for demolition
by Dan Whisenhunt
Staff Writer
Jun 30, 2009 | 5408 views | 20 20 comments | 45 45 recommendations | email to a friend | print
A stone mound created by American Indians sits behind the Oxford Exchange. Workers are using the dirt from the hill as fill for a new Sam s Club. Photo: Stephen Gross/The Anniston Star
A stone mound created by American Indians sits behind the Oxford Exchange. Workers are using the dirt from the hill as fill for a new Sam's Club. Photo: Stephen Gross/The Anniston Star
slideshow
OXFORD — A stone mound on a hill behind the Oxford Exchange created by American Indians 1,500 years ago will soon disappear.

And whether Oxford's taxpayers wanted it or not, they paid for its destruction.

Workers hired by the city's Commercial Development Authority are using the dirt from the hill as fill for a new Sam's Club. The project has angered American Indians who, along with a Jacksonville State University archaeology professor, say the site could contain human remains.

Oxford Mayor Leon Smith and City Project Manager Fred Denney say it was used to send smoke signals.

The city's CDA uses taxpayer money and assets to lure commercial businesses. The $2.6 million no-bid CDA contract for preparing the Sam's site went to Oxford-based Taylor Corp. That money came from the sale of city property to Georgia-based developers Abernathy and Timberlake and from additional money provided by the city.

In Alabama, CDAs are exempt from bid laws, meaning contracts can go to whichever company the board chooses. Oxford's CDA board and its actions have multiple connections to Smith's political fundraising:

• At least three board members or their employers have contributed to his political campaigns.

• Taylor Corp., under the ownership of Tommy Taylor, has received thousands of dollars in city contracts for non-CDA work. Taylor donated $1,000 to Smith in 2004 and $1,000 in 2008.

• Abernathy and Timberlake donated $1,000 to Smith's re-election campaign in 2004.

• Montgomery-based Goodwyn, Mills and Cawood donated $500 to Smith in 2004. The CDA gave the company engineering contracts for the exchange. Denney said the CDA paid the company $45,000 for engineering work, part of which paid for a University of Alabama Study on the American Indian Site.

The Star has so far been unable to obtain a copy of the UA study, but a letter from the Alabama Historical Commission's deputy state historic preservation officer indicated the university did not think the site was eligible for the National Register of Historic Places. The state Historic Preservation Commission did think the site was eligible for the National Register.

Denney said the report's authors found little at the site.

Smith has said there is nothing wrong with the connections between himself and the CDA. He has described Taylor as a, "good friend."

Attempts to reach representatives for Taylor Corp. and Abernathy and Timberlake on Monday were unsuccessful.

The Birmingham office of Goodwyn, Mills and Cawood declined comment.

CDA members contacted by The Star declined comment, referring questions to board chairman Dwight Rice. Attempts to reach Rice on Monday also were unsuccessful.

Chervis Isom, a Birmingham attorney representing Abernathy and Timberlake, said the company isn't involved with the hill or the fill dirt.

"If the dirt were contaminated in some way we'd certainly have an interest in that," Isom said. "Where the CDA got the dirt I'm not sure. We don't have any control over that."

He added he does not think there is any problem with the dirt.

Denney said workers will remove about one-third of the hill and cover it with grass. The city eventually will develop commercial business on what remains of the hill, he said.

A September 2008 proposal by Taylor Corp. describes the demolition in vague terms.

"This item includes undercutting two building pad footprints ..." the report reads. "The City has agreed to let us spoil the undercut material on their property across the new bridge." Denney said the line in the proposal refers to the hill.

"The agreement was we'd furnish the soil," Denney said. "The city would furnish them a place to get it."

The City Council transferred the property containing the hill to the CDA in February. Councilwoman June Land Reaves, who voted against the transfer, said she did not understand the hill property was a part of it.

"I never heard any discussion about dirt being taken from the hillside or a reason why that was being done, but it seems to me like a lot of cities capitalize on the history they have… but (we do not seem) to do that," she said.

Council President Chris Spurlin said it's too late for the City Council to intervene at the site. He said he hated the bad publicity, but said there is no proof the site holds human remains.

"The CDA has the authority," Spurlin said. "They're trying to do what's best for the city. I don't see no reason in buying fill dirt from someone when we have that hill available."
comments (20)
« Librul wrote on Thursday, Aug 13 at 09:41 PM »
As the kids say,

You go Girl! (or guy)

:)

« pocahantus wrote on Thursday, Aug 13 at 08:49 PM »
I was born in Oxford, Al. and understand very well the good 'ole boy political system in place now and has always been in place in that town. The average citizen will keep their heads in the sand as long as Leon Smith can put another junk retail store on the corner. It should be criminal to destroy a 1500 year old Indian mound for pirates who have no respect for history or humanity to desecrate for an under the table deal. I think I'll call CNN and let them check out Mr Smith and this black-hearted deal.
« Librul wrote on Thursday, Aug 13 at 08:22 PM »
Pocahantus,

This is all just my opinion.

Many of the people in Oxford overlook what he is because of what they think he has done for Oxford.

The Star calls him out, but it doesn't seem to help. I'm not saying they say he is a crook, but they do point out some of the shenannigans he is involved in.

He is not mentally stable. I am betting that one day he will pull a Woody Hays. That will be his undoing.

And so he was a bouncer? Wow.... I'm sure many of the posters here are aware of the rumors of his past in Tennessee....

« pocahantus wrote on Thursday, Aug 13 at 07:56 PM »
Leon Smith Says Indians only sent smoke signals from the mound? Where did he get credentials to make this determination? I would like to know exactly what educational credential Smith has to determine anything. He first appeared around Anniston-Oxford as a bouncer in a bar. How quickly we do forget. If his mamma was buried in there and he could make a buck out of it he would blow it up. People don't sit on your cans and let this happen.
« NeyomFriday wrote on Thursday, Aug 06 at 01:06 AM »
Dear POS Leon Smith,

My name is Neyom Friday.

You will not get away with this.

For anyone wanting to help and stop this ignorant mess please feel free to contact me at

neyom.friday@gmail.com

In hope and faith,

Neyom Friday
« tugboatcharlie wrote on Monday, Jul 06 at 06:38 PM »
I was by there today and it looked like only 4 trees were left on top.
« DownSouth wrote on Monday, Jul 06 at 05:43 PM »
kamarie,

I agree with you. I'm sure you notice that your explanation of the facts in the matter silenced all the local Smith supporters.

The King has no clothes on....

Regards,
« kmarie wrote on Wednesday, Jul 01 at 08:57 PM »
Okay, I am an archaeologist, and I know for a fact that both these men are breaking laws. The only thing is that they have all of the politicians in the area in pocket, so everyone is covering everyone else. I know a few U of A archaeologist, and they would not say a mound has no significance. That is very specific wording which goes into a federal law. Also, NAGPRA, a federal law, states that any significant Native American site which may contain burials must be mitigated, not destroyed, which means the site would have to be excavated properly, not just surveyed. Does anyone know just where the permits are coming from? And where the contract money is coming from? Is it all city and local, because if not, if any of it comes from the state or federal government he is breaking yet another federal law. AND, if the site is still up for review as to whether or not it IS significant, he is breaking another law, by not waiting until the state archaeologist has had time to review the site and list it on the National Register, which would give the city revenue for not destroying it, and it would be protected from ever being disturbed by anyone, no matter who they have paid off. Any further information on what is going on here would be helpful to stop this from happening.
« Oxford resident wrote on Wednesday, Jul 01 at 12:10 AM »
Don't ya'll know that King Leon doesn't have to play by the rules? Now he has all but 2 council members in his pockets, he can really do what he chooses! June Reaves and Steven Waits are the only ones on the council that have a mind of their own and are not scared of King Leon! I would love to see someone get Leon for all of his dirty dealings. Who knows? Maybe it's in the works? He and Sigleman and Schrushy could share a cell!!!!
« AlabamaPines wrote on Tuesday, Jun 30 at 09:22 PM »
Growing up would mean having some thought for the next generation. Do our kids want more temporary box stores, or would they like us to preserve something that lasted 1500 years? Growing up would mean sorting through the evidence--especially that given by archeologists and historical experts. Don't we care about the richness of our cultural heritage--or do we just want to make a buck? Growing up would mean being responsible about the kind of community we want to create. Previous generations were that grown up. Why aren't we?
« oxfordresident wrote on Tuesday, Jun 30 at 08:19 PM »
I really don't see the problem. If it is such a historical spot, why hasn't anyone done anything about it before now. All of a sudden, now that someone wants to bring it down, it is a historical piece of land and shouldn't be taken down. Please people, are we that childish that we have to fight over a piece of land that may or may not be historical!!! Grow up!
« tugboatcharlie wrote on Tuesday, Jun 30 at 12:56 PM »
I went by there this morning and they are already digging dirt from right on top of the mound. More than likely the trees and the rocks will be gone today. Turn out the lights, the party's over.
« unpc wrote on Tuesday, Jun 30 at 12:04 PM »
Bobby, I don't know much about this overall issue but I have noticed many subtle attacks on Smith.

You think maybe they want to get him out of office so they can hire him at Anniston?
« ravenspiritwalker wrote on Tuesday, Jun 30 at 11:20 AM »
Harry Holstein of JSU archaeology department has surveyed this site and by his authority states this is a sacred site. I find it interesting that no one will produce the findings from U of A. Maybe because it confirms what everyone is saying that this hill is worth preserving. I cannot understand why fill dirt can't be taken from somewhere else in the county. How about helping out JSU with trying to find a place to put their fill dirt from the expansion of the football stadium. That would be a logical solution so this is why the CDA will not go for that idea. To destroy the history in this county is just another example of money being more important to the politicians and the CDA in Oxford. Too bad this is the way mayor Smith wants to be remembered. I bet if the Davis family knew this is the way their land would be used by the city they would have never donated to Oxford.
« Bobby_G wrote on Tuesday, Jun 30 at 10:58 AM »
Has anyone noticed that there doesn't seem to be any actual evidence that there ever was a native american site at this location? Go back and read all the articles, I think the best you will find is innuendo or otherwise misleading statements by people who ought to know better. There was mention of what appeared to be a piece of broken pottery in one survey. If one piece of pottery is enough to claim an area as a historical site we are all in trouble. There could be broken pottery scattered here and there all over the state. People moving about, with walking as their only transportation, probably broke a lot of pots during their travels. To date, and to my knowledge, no reputable individual or organization has stated unequivocally that this is a historical native american site. When they were able to get comments from them, they came away with "could've" "maybe" "etc". The reason is that literally every square inch of America could be a site, but without some evidence, no one is going to set aside property just in case someone wants to dig it "sometime".

In hindsight, this series of articles appear to be just another attempt to denigrate the efforts of Mayor Smith. The Star is able to influence some of the voters in Oxford but the number remains low. Most recognized quickly the purpose of the articles, solely on evaluation of the evidence provided.
« slal wrote on Tuesday, Jun 30 at 09:49 AM »
You can move a mountain but, can you move a cesspool?
« borderdog wrote on Tuesday, Jun 30 at 09:44 AM »
How does Oxford mayor Leon Smith know that "the 1500 year old hilltop ain't no grave site, but was used to send smoke signals"?
« rabbimonty@bellsouth.net wrote on Tuesday, Jun 30 at 06:53 AM »
Forget the argument that it's a burial mound. It IS part of a Appalachian Ridge line of other stone monuments and they are all connected to the Woodland Indians. Even if it's not a burial site, it took hundreds of man-hours to build. It could be turned into a Gem that would attract tourists. As travelers pass Exits 185 & 188 they see signs that direct them to our highest point, Cheaha..........30 miles out of the way. At this site they could stop, take a mini Historical stroll and spend a few tourist bucks at the Oxford Exchange, and continue on their journey marveling that the citizens of Calhoun County have such a rich exotic history.
« Monty Clendenin wrote on Tuesday, Jun 30 at 06:44 AM »
I talked to Mayor Smith yesterday. He will receive in the mail today an alternative proposal for the site where everyone wins. Sams Club, The Native Americans and even the city of Oxford. I can't believe there is NO way to stop this with some legel injunction, Please, someone with the right legal skills step forward. I have sent a crude, cut and paste concept to the Star. As sophmoric as it is I wish they would publish it. It at least starts the imagination to grasp the vision.
« anonymous wrote on Tuesday, Jun 30 at 06:09 AM »
Spurlin says the CDA has the authority. I don't believe this is true. Someone from outside of the state needs to investigate this. ADEM and the EPA needs to be involved in this.