Bob Davis: A certain je ne sais quoi — Say this about Tim James: He’s full of chutzpah
Apr 30, 2010 | 1790 views | 10 10 comments | 18 18 recommendations | email to a friend | print
“This is Alabama, we speak English.”

— Tim James, candidate for governor, speaking in a campaign commercial decrying that Alabama offers driver’s license exams in 12 languages


What, is he loco? If this ninja candidate was feeling angst at recent polling and looking for a way to add panache to his bid to be Alabama’s next governor, James found it. With this YouTube sensation, he can say “sayonara” to campaigning under the radar.

Or, as famed Spanish explorer Hernando de Soto might say, “Se trata de Alabama. Hablamos Inglés.”

So, what was the motivation — the raison d’être — of the man The New York Times called, “The Candidate From Xenophobia?”

Here’s a guess. In a Republican primary field with loads of gubernatorial competitors pushing the dial further rightward, James found himself in deep kimchi. One 30-second jiu jitsu move later and — voilà! — James is au courant with the “papers, please” zeitgeist springing from Arizona.

Or, as they say at the Mercedes plant in Vance, “Dies ist Alabama. Wir sprechen Englisch.”

English, researchers tell us, is a pastiche of other languages. One study found that of the 100 most commonly used words in English, 80 percent are Germanic. Another study found that 40 percent of the 10,000 most commonly used words come from French, a notion bound to make lovers of “freedom fries” see red.

All of this is to say that it takes a lot of chutzpah to act as if English isn’t a mash-up of scores of languages. Yet, James takes a serious look into the camera and says, “We’re only giving that test in English if I’m governor.”

Oy vey!

Or, as they say down at the Hyundai plant in Montgomery, “Igeos-eun allabama, ulineun yeong-eoleul sseubnida.”

It costs $28.50 for a person to take a test and purchase an Alabama driver’s license; for point of reference, that’s 21.49 in Euros, 194.53 in Yuan and 1,268.67 in Rupees.

James argues that reducing the test’s number of languages from 12 to one is a matter of smart economics. “Maybe it’s just the businessman in me, but we’ll save money and it makes sense,” he said.

A story on the Los Angeles Times’ website casts doubt upon that claim, suggesting James’ proposal might lead to a sort of economic hara kiri.

“Compared to the cost of additional accidents from untested drivers and the damage to the state’s image, it’s a drop in the bucket,” Outside the Beltway blogger James Joyner told the Times. “If one company decides to go to South Carolina or Tennessee rather than Alabama over this issue, it’ll be bad business, indeed.”

Also speaking with the L.A. Times, University of Alabama professor David Lanoue agreed, “It seems almost certain that any money saved by not administering multi-language tests would be more than offset by the legal fees the state would incur when the law was challenged in court.”

Or, as the French executives from Airbus currently angling to build an airplane manufacturing facility in Mobile would say, “Il s’agit d’Alabama. Nous parlons anglais.”

We might as well acknowledge that “Alabama” isn’t an English word. Turns out we took the land and the name from the Indians who called this area home long before Europeans started exploring it in the 16th century.

Would a James administration put the kibosh on Alabama cities with non-English names? What about Florence, which takes its name from the Italian city? Or Andalusia (Spain)? Or Elba (Italy)? Let’s not even consider what we would call the north Alabama town of Arab.

What will we call kindergartens? Will searching for a moment of zen register as a faux pas? Will turning in per diem expenses become verboten?

Must we only seize the day, but never carpe diem? Will the savoir-faire among us be forced to become more like a schlemiel?

Will our neighboring states revel in a sense of schadenfreude when the worst becomes a fait accompli?

It could set off a mêlée, if not a pogrom in cities and towns across the state.

Or, as the top executives from Honda might say when visiting the company’s operations in Lincoln, “Kore wa arabama-sh? desu. Wareware wa eigo o hanasu.”

Sadly, James’ bold ad is de rigueur in a state practically swimming in tea parties. Here Republican candidates cannot be too conservative and tough talk on non-English speakers is the lingua franca. What options does someone trailing the pack have?

The Greenville businessman decided to turn the knob past 11, apparently ignoring the praiseworthy work down by Gov. Bob Riley in attracting international companies to Alabama. With only a few weeks left before the June 1 primary, James faced up to the timetable and fading chances at electoral glory.

Though he probably wouldn’t put it this way, James is acknowledging a well-known phrase, “Sic transit gloria.”

Bob Davis is editor of The Anniston Star. Contact him at (256) 235-3540 or bdavis@annistonstar.com. You can follow him on Twitter at: twitter.com/EditorBobDavis. He offers full credit to Google Translate for assisting with this column.
comments (10)
« alvinhurst@cableone.net wrote on Thursday, May 13 at 11:03 AM »
mtp, excellent. I agree completely. And I don't expect you to get an answer from the Star.

Why don't they print the Star in several languages to accomodate those who can't read English? As usual, liberal want to enforce their compassion on everyone else but exempt themselves.
« jsu6829d@jsu.edu wrote on Thursday, May 13 at 10:55 AM »
im not quite sure how i feel about this one, but for the most part i agree with you who feel that people who are here should learn to speak english. we are making an awful lot of conveniences for the spanish speaking community. is it ok to make warning labels, and assembly instructions only in spanish? or should we pick and choose what we allow in spanish. your thoughts please. great example about the Star mtp926.
« mtp926@yahoo.com wrote on Saturday, May 01 at 05:05 PM »
lol...good one, rjack112. Maybe we need to explain to Mr. Davis the definition of "logic".
« birdbrain2@mail.com wrote on Saturday, May 01 at 04:09 PM »
mtp, how dare you confuse these people with logic? It's like Greek to them...uh...Spanish? German?

Mucho grassyass...
« mtp926@yahoo.com wrote on Saturday, May 01 at 03:40 PM »
If a German who could not speak English wanted a job at the Anniston Star, would they hire him and then require all other Star employees to learn to speak German instead of telling the German that he needs to learn to speak English? Would the Star editors all settle down to learning to speak German - or would they put the foreigner in a janitor's suit and give him a broom to push after every one else had gone home for the night?

Ok, we'll say they hired the German who can't speak English.

Now, here comes a Frenchman who can't speak English. I ask the same questions as I did about the German.

Then in the front door of the Star walks a Russian who can't speak English. I ask the same questions as I did about the German and the Frenchman.

And then a Mexican comes in for a job. Same questions.

Surely, even the editors at the Star are smart enough to realize that the German, The Frenchman, the Russian, and the Mexican need to learn to speak English because that is the language that is commonly spoken here in America, the common language that is spoken at the Anniston Star. Surely, they would not insist that all the Star employees learn four different languages.

Surely, they would not want to spend the money (and have to put up with the aggravation) to post every written memo, notice, warning, instructions, etc., in five languages - English, German, French, Russian and Spanish - and then have to do any and all updates in 5 different languages.

How many people who can't speak English are working at the Star? None? 1? 25?

Yet the Star editors expect everybody else to bend over backwards for someone who's not interested in speaking and reading the English language. My response to that - go back to your own country and speak your own language to your heart's content!

And, by the way, Mr. Davis, I might not sound as educated as you but I already know that the words in our English language came from other languages, or as you put it: "a pastiche of other languages". I guess you're just dying for someone to ask the definition of "pastiche", aren't you? lol

And what does that have to do with expecting people to speak and read our English language if they want to live in America? I think all you saw was a chance to write an article where you could show off your 'fancy words and book-learning'. Well, that, plus show your liberal side and run down common sense.

« pooter@gmail.com wrote on Saturday, May 01 at 12:12 PM »
Well, if 'Tim the Foolman' James wants everyone to master English.... better start with native Alabamians.. ROFLMAO Yes, I am one too!!! I confess. 'Sometimes we just don't talk too good'.. HA HA HA
« bcolburn@cableone.net wrote on Saturday, May 01 at 10:56 AM »
Never understood why we would want to issue a drivers' License to a foreign national anyway. There is such a thing as an "International Drivers' License". It is issued by the home country when a citizen going to travel abroad. There is a test and on passing it the home country certifies the person capable of driving safely. It was part of the reason we agreed to put up "International Roadsigns". Almost every country does this. Wonder why we even let none citizens take the test?
« jamht1972@yahoo.com wrote on Saturday, May 01 at 05:55 AM »
Tim James is right. Supporting a public policy that would result in unqualified foreign speaking drivers (since they can't take the test in their own language) on the roads of Alabama makes so much more sense.
« bcolburn@cableone.net wrote on Friday, Apr 30 at 08:56 PM »
I've been having a chuckle over that ad myself. I remember just a few years ago the same problem arose, seems the test was only given in English. Some lady from a South American country, not sure which, was all set to launch a civil suit, backed by some liberal group to get it changed. Based on this, I've been wondering how we save money?

James also touts his love of common sense, looks like very little common sense went into this ad!
« alvinhurst@cableone.net wrote on Friday, Apr 30 at 08:45 PM »
Does Honda prefer to hire people who speak English? I don't know but a question that should have been addressed in this article, since you borught it up.

But you may have misse the real crux of this. James did not look good and the reason is that he had no good answer as to whether this was a political ploy.

He should have known that question was coming and this should have been his answer -- Every politician says things to get votes. That is what it is all about. The real question should be, do I believe what I say? Yes, I do believe what I say. I believe that people who stay in the US should speak English, the language of this country. That that statement will also get votes is fine with me.

I could have said, I intend to give everyone two thousand dollars. That would also get votes. But I do not believe that would be the thing to do and I would be wrong in saying that. But I said something that I beleive in and if it gets me votes then that is why I am running.

But he stammered and diverted and did not answer the question properly. That tells me he is not ready for prime time.

But as to the issue, h--- yes we should speak English! This is America and English is our langange. If I go to France I expect to speak French. That is why I don't go there.